The more I drive the more I would agree - at idle it's about as effective as the stock fan ever was. But as soon as you're moving at all, it's far, far better, moves so much more air and temps drop pretty rapidly even on a stinking hot 35c+ day. The one thing I've noticed most of all is with uphill driving. Where I live it's fairly hilly, and I often drive uphill a fair bit to go to certain shops or parks where I go fossicking, and on the stock fan temps would always gradually work their way up towards 100c while doing sustained uphill stretches. On this ZJ clutch, I can drive the whole way up and it's always sitting at about 75-80c at most. Even if I stop at some lights and it creeps up a bit, as soon as I start moving again the temps drop off rapidly.
So yeah, at lower speeds you won't notice the difference a whole lot. But if you're highway cruising, going fast-ish or doing uphill drives or anything that keeps the rpm's up, it's a world of difference!
I'm very happy so far